Australia without cloud computing industry

A study by IT services analyst group Longhaus has failed to locate a single service provider in Australia whose offering meets the true definition of a cloud computing service.

Whilst many Australian service providers claim to offer some kind of service in the cloud, Longhaus research director Sam Higgins told iTnews that not a single data centre operator in the country offers a service that fits the technical criteria for cloud computing.

“When you scratch beyond their use of the word ‘cloud’, you find they are offering nothing more than the provision of virtual servers,” he said. “They are not offering truly elastic computing power.”

Under the virtual server provisioning model, the customer is allocated a pre-defined server image from the service provider, plus access to a control panel or interface for the managing of what the customer chooses to do with the virtual server. This, says Higgins, is not cloud computing.

“This is an image controlled by a service provider,” he said. “The customer might be offered four or five options around what that image is, but you are still being charged for idle time.

“Just because something is virtual, it doesn’t instantly make it a cloud computing offering.”

Under a more strict definition of cloud computing , the service needs to be dynamic, he said.

“You as a customer define the web server image, you set the memory and processing needs as you see fit, you set up the load balancing, and you are charged for what you use rather than for the mere existence of the server,” he said.

Higgins said there are plenty of “platform as a service” or “software as a service” options, which are sometimes mistakenly lumped under the umbrella term of ‘cloud computing’. There are also “private cloud” offerings touted by the likes of IBM and Fujitsu.

Hostworks founder Marty Gauvin, now planning to invest in the cloud computing space, says it is understandable that the dominant cloud deployments at this stage are private clouds.

“Public cloud services have to overcome a range of issues such as security, service levels and compatibility before they can take a larger share of enterprise business,” he said.

Local companies such as Firstservis are experimenting with public cloud services – but Higgins claims they are merely reselling 3Tera’s ‘cloud-based operating system’ AppLogic.

“They are really only offering an Australian dollar conversion to a U.S. service,” Higgins said.

Higgins said the main hosting companies in the market – Macquarie Telecom, Melbourne IT and Hostworks – are unable to offer cloud computing as they “have enough problems with legacy drag around shared hosting.”

“It is a big enough challenge for them to move to a virtual environment let alone the cloud,” he said. “They are not in a position to re-engineer all their legacy technology at massive expense.”

Plurk This Post Delicious Digg This Post MySpace Ping This Post Reddit This Post Stumble This Post